Hardy Boys Webzine | ![]() | Hardy Boys Home Page |
| Bayport Beat |
Hardy scholar Tony Carpentieri has announced that several of the Grosset & Dunlap Hardy Boys stories are to be slightly modified to correct spelling, grammar and punctuation errors for their 1999 printings.
See you next time!
| Hardy Boys News |


| The Call Of Chethulhu |
Chapter One - The Bayport Horror
| Ghost Story |
| Bayport Mail Bag |
From: bl030@cleveland.Freenet.Edu (Joseph T. Arendt)
This is a response to a column in the last issue of Bayport Times.
In The Bayport Times #12, Robert C. Nuel wrote, "We (and I'm speaking for myself here, and maybe some of you) read them [Hardy Boys books] because they remind us of a time in our lives when everything was simpler. A time when we didn't scrutinize everything for logic."
For much of what Mr. Nuel wrote, he certainly is speaking for himself and not for me! I turned to Hardy Boys as a boy because I could no longer handle the lack of logic in comic books. How did Superman stay in the air? What did Batman attach his rope to? Why didn't villians remove the superheros' masks after capturing them? What was burning as fuel when the Human Torch burned or was he consuming his own flesh? Questions like this tormented me and drove me away from comic books. I could never read the comic book Flash without getting a splitting headache since his speed stunts confused me so much with their impossibility. Instead, I turned to the far more believable and far more logical Hardy Boys! It was because of scrutizing for logic that I became interested in the Hardy Boys, not the opposite.
I got annoyed when the Hardy Boys books didn't seem logical, although at that age, I admit it never occurred to me how hard it would be to hold a conversation while on a roaring motorcycle. It was immediately obvious that books like _The Disappearing Floor_ had the old comic book style illogic, though! I hated that one! However, I confess that as an adult, I find _The Disappearing Floor_ to have an odd charm that I never appreciated as a kid. I've got a collection of Superman comics now too, even though I didn't like Superman as a kid because the powers made no physical sense to me. It bothers me less now then it did then.
Robert C. Nuel also wrote, "The Hardy Boys are a window into other epochs in American adolescence. Times when boys and girls didn't drink, smoke dope (except for "Crooked Arrows"), have torrid sex in the backseat of their cars...and were generally respectful to their elders."
When I was a boy first reading the Hardy Boys, I wasn't yet interested in the mushy romance stuff. The types of movies Mom liked bored me to tears. Girls were all right as friends if they would join in with various games and adventures. Romance didn't much enter into it. Not yet. This being so, I wasn't much interested in involved romance in the stories either. I was aware that torrid sex in backseats of cars did happen...I wasn't that stupid...but it wasn't interesting to me yet. I certainly didn't drink at that age! I mean, come on, I was about ten or eleven years old!
The Hardy Boys, as they were written, fit my interests very well when I first started reading them.
After all, I thought the target age group was 12 year old boys, although I remember being proud of reading them at a younger age, having to ask Mom, Dad, or Grandma what some words meant. I also remember being so proud to be given a hard cover books. I had a stack sitting on my dresser, carefully ordered and lined up. I loved the way these books looked and felt! I still do!
How many boys in that target age group are yet that interested in sex, booze, and drugs? Granted, I have heard that some 12 years olds are already into all three. That is a huge sociological shift from when I was that age!
By the time I was 14 or 15, I no longer interested in the Hardy Boys books. For one thing, by then I was interested in girls and the Hardy Boys books were unsatisfying in that department. Instead, my interests switched to the Robert Anson Heinlein science fiction novels designed for boys that often did have more going on with romance. It was still very tame by today's standards, but the male protagonist sometimes did obviously bed the desired woman character even if not given in detail. It had some scandalous ideas, tolerated by being science fiction. Heinlein's _The Moon is a Harsh Mistress_ talked about group marriages, for example, with the protagonist in one. I was amazed to get a book with an idea like that from the library! The Hardy Boys it was not!
I suspect if you get out of the big cities, for much of the rest of America, the interests of 12 year old boys might not be that drastically changed as they were when I was that age, unlike TV news might have everybody think. I could be wrong, though. Of course, by the time I really was 17 and 18 as were the Hardy Boys stated ages, things were very different. When I was 10, 11, and 12 years old and contentedly reading the Hardy Boys books, it was a different story.
When I read a Hardy Boys book now, though, it often is for nostalgia. In fact, I like the original-text books from Twenties and Thirties best, so it is nostalgia for an era I certainly never lived in.
Robert C. Nuel also wrote, "How many sixteen year olds do we know who can walk up to the chief of police in a town, carry on an intelligent conversation, and be taken seriously? None."
Personally, I liked some of the earliest books when Patrolman Riley, Officer Smuff, and Chief Collig most certainly did not take the Hardy boys seriously, discounting them since they were mere boys. In the end, the police who wouldn't listen to the boys ended up with egg on their face. Oh, I loved that!
As the folks say in the usenet newsgroups, all this was very much only IN MY HUMBLE OPINION (IMHO)!
Readers - This is your forum to tell the world your thoughts on the Hardys!
Letters may be edited for content, spelling etc. but, then again, maybe not!
Full name & e-mail address required for your letter to appear here.
Help support The Bayport Times & the Hardy Boys Homepage! |
100's of Hardy Boys and other series books & collectibles! Many Hardy Boys titles recently added! |
I've listed all the Hardy Boys book by series and number - just click & buy! You can also search the AMAZON.COM book data base from here! |
Check It Out! The Bayport Connection A Hardy Boys Message Board.
All Rights Reserved |
To contact me by e-mail fwdixon@yahoo.com